The Art of Arranging a Song

The Art of Arranging a Song

SEPTEMBER 25th, 2018


“Music is the mediator between the spiritual and the sensual life.” – Ludwig van Beethoven


Imagine I gave you a sunflower, a dozen carnations, and then asked you to arrange them into a bouquet. What would you do?

After a few strange looks, I imagine you’d place the sunflower in the center with the smaller flowers around to support it. It’s not that it’s the right answer, but it’s the obvious one.

Now what if I gave you a dozen assorted flowers – all different shapes and colors –  and asked you to arrange those.

Not as easy, right?

That leads me to the first and most important point about arrangement:

Find Your Centerpiece

It can be a bitter pill to swallow, especially since you know the time and energy that went into getting those layered claps just right… but not all sounds in your mix deserve the spotlight. In fact, the spotlight is really only big enough to focus on one or two elements at once.

Imagine if every background character tried talking over Tom Cruise. It would be Mission Impossible to make it through without losing your mind. It’s easier and more effective to make arrangement decisions when you decide in advance which tracks are most important, and what’s there to support those critical few.

I can’t stress this enough: a good arrangement is about taking the centerpiece of your song and building a frame around it.

By the end of this article, you’ll know:

  1. The three types of arrangement, and why you shouldn’t believe the myth that arrangement is just about the order of sections in your song
  2. Why arrangement in music is important, and how it relates to your number one goal as a producer (which is finishing songs, right?)
  3. When you should think about arranging a song
  4. The mindset shift that will turn your loop into an arranged song every time, and finally:
  5. The Hyperbits Six Keys to a Better Arrangement

The Biggest Myth About Arranging A Song

What is arrangement? On one hand, it’s obvious. Arrangement is the flow of a song from start to finish. It has sections: like an intro, verse, buildup, chorus, breakdown, drop, and outro.

And sure, that’s arrangement in a traditional sense. That’s arrangement of the different movements within your music. No doubt about it, you need to make those decisions when you’re arranging a song. We’ll cover how to do that.

But if you believe that’s all there is to arrangement, you’re missing a whole framework for crafting beautiful compositions. Arrangement is a way of looking at your track from several angles to carve away the excess and support what’s already working. Simply choosing the order of sections doesn’t guarantee a song that captivates your listener’s attention.

There are actually three types of arrangement, and it takes making active decisions about all three to get your track up to par with the music you love.

First (and most familiar) is structural arrangement, which is the movement of energy, sections and transitions in your music. Next is instrumental arrangement – how the notes, chords, and melodies are laid out across the the different instruments in your ensemble. Remember, this can change during the course of your track! Moving the melody line from a vocal to a synth can drive it home in a new and refreshing way. Finally there’s spatial arrangement, which is placing sounds within your mix by determining their volume, panning, and sense of presence. Here is that list in form of pretty bullet points to make this as simple as possible.

  1. Structural Arrangement
  2. Instrumental Arrangement
  3. Spatial Arrangement

That’s a lot to take in, so let’s keep trying to simplify this. At the end of the day, arrangement solves:

  1. Flow
  2. Voicing
  3. Mix

The Importance of Arrangement in Music

Have you ever had a friend tell you a story they swear is hilarious? It’s built up with details that are totally lost on you, and it’s not until they’re done that you realized you missed the punchline. We all know what comes next: “Ahh… I guess you had to be there.”

Compare that to reliving an inside joke, where even a tone of voice or hand gesture can bring back a flood of memories from some ridiculous situation you experienced together.

That’s the difference between a poorly executed idea and a well-polished arrangement.

When I wrote about why dynamics in music are the key to emotional productions, it was to show how many different words within our musical vocabulary all point to this hidden, underlying theme. In a similar fashion, I want you to replace the word “arrangement” with a new word, one that will help you focus on an action. Bring out your mental dictionaries and pencil this in: Arrangement is all about “Arrival”.

Time To Arrange

So far we’ve been talking about arranging a song, but I want to be more specific. What makes a song a song is it’s arrangement. With this article, I want to show you how to arrange an idea INTO a song.

If you’ve been producing music for longer than a day, you know how many decisions need to be made within the process. The best producers out there have built a system of working through these decisions and sticking with them. You don’t want to be thinking about structural arrangement after you’ve recorded the final vocal. And seriously, you don’t need to get bogged down with the details of mix arrangement when you’re developing a chord progression.

Here’s the Hyperbits Methodology for when you should arrange, based on the three types we’ve identified.

Voicing (Instruments)

Determining which instruments carry the melody, chords, and harmony can come first in the process or at the very end. It’s important to know that both options are available, but it’s still a decision you need to make, whether that’s in the conception phase or when the rest of the track is built out.

Some producers like to start with a simple piano patch to build out their chords. Others prefer to take care of sound design first. Got a sweet sounding polysynth? Go ahead and lay some chords down with it. Between the two, I’m in favor of whatever works best for you and your workflow.

That being said, you’ll need to make voicing decisions at some point, and sound design early in the process has its benefits. If you decide to put those chords on a 80’s sounding polysynth instead of a rhodes piano, it will change the direction and vibe of your track. I’m a fan of making decisions and moving quickly, but you’ll need to find what works best for you. Just remember that the assignment of melody and harmony across instruments is where sound design and arrangement meet, and it’s not to be overlooked.

Flow (Structure)

You should be thinking about arranging for flow once you have a basic idea built out. Maybe that’s an 8-bar loop, a chord progression and melody, or a high energy phrase that would make a great drop.

Right now, you don’t have a song. You have an idea, which is seriously exciting. But in order for it to be a song, it needs a different section. You’ve got B, now you need A. There’s a mindset shift we’ll cover below that will let you take any section of music and create its counterpart, but more on that in a moment.

Those that know me will know what’s coming, but it’s so important that it bears mentioning again. And again.

In order to create great music, you need to reference.

Using tried and true forms is surprisingly liberating. It’s actually a lot easier to create fresh and inventive music within constraints than it is to try to reinvent the wheel every time you’re writing. Referencing is as simple as dragging a song you admire in to your DAW, warping it to match your song’s tempo, and adding flags or markers at the beginning of every new section. You don’t need to adhere perfectly to every bar, but let it be a loose guideline for your song’s structure. Once you’ve got a structure to work towards, we can easily take this idea and reverse engineer a way to built up to it.

If I’m being honest, there are hundreds, if not thousands of blog posts about ‘getting out of the loop.’ In one way or another, they all are suggesting a variation of exactly what we just suggested.

That said, don’t overthink this. Drag that reference track directly into your DAW, warp to your BPM, and map out a guide for yourself. There will be plenty (and I mean plenty) of opportunities to stray from this structural map later in the production process.

Mix (Space)

Arranging the elements within your track to create a cohesive mix is beyond the scope of this article, but it comes after the flow and voicing is established. In other words, you mix once you’ve finished the song.

If you couldn’t tell already, I absolutely geek out on the art of mixing. I’ve spent years learning what makes a great mix, and it takes time to teach the methodology and technical skills required. If you’re at the point where flow and voicing decisions are starting to come naturally, you’d learn a ton from our Mix Master Flow and Masterclass. If you’re looking for something that follows the journey of a song from composition through the mixdown, our Start to Finish courses would give you a great perspective into how these different types of arrangement all work together.

The Mindset Shift for Turning Loops Into Songs

Here’s a lessons I keep re-learning in my career as a music producer:

It’s easier to take away what’s already there than trying to add what isn’t.

Filtering frequencies out of a synth, using reductive EQ, hitting the mute button…these are simple actions, but 9 times out of 10 they’re more effective for creating headroom and space in the mix than boosting or adding new sounds.

The same principle applies to arrangement. Reduce, don’t add.

This is a methodology known as Subtractive Arrangement, and it’s been covered by everyone from ill Gates to Dennis DeSantos from Ableton.

The loop you’ve built will ultimately be your final chorus. Copy and paste it so you have 3-4 minutes of material. Keep it at full blast for that last chorus, but for your other sections, MUTE as many tracks as you can get away with. Once you’ve got a bare skeleton with a few shared elements, you can add a new instrument if you desire. With that simple move, you’ve backed your way into an A section for the B section you’ve already built.

Remember: arrangement is arrival. This is where the fun comes in with transitions, buildups, and creating tension for that full frequency release.

Subtractive Arrangement. It’s a mindset that will let you turn any idea into a song, and it requires working backwards from the idea you have by removing tracks until you have scaffolding on which to hang a buildup.

Hyperbits Six Keys to a Better Arrangement

Arrangement is one of the most important skills to cultivate as a producer, because it covers everything from mixdown to how you arrive at the idea that initially inspired you. Here are our six keys for building better arrangements.

  1. A good arrangement is one where the song ends a hair too soon. It’s better to air on the side of concluding a second too early instead of running a second too long. Would you rather your listener immediately rewind, or lost their interest by overstaying your welcome? Keep your songs shorter, simpler, and to the point.
  2. I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it at least a thousand more times. Reference other music. It will only help. I’m dead serious about this. To reference one of my favorite books, you should Steal Like an Artist.
  3. Use varying degrees of dynamics to move between sections. A restrained, reigned in verse will feel more impactful moving to a big chorus than if everything was big and loud from the first bar. And on that note, dynamics are amazing.
  4. Take a risk and try something new. You owe it to yourself. Maybe it’s a bold sound design move for a transition, a new way of using a synth or effect…this isn’t just a way to keep your arrangements fresh and interesting, but a way to keep yourself engaged and challenged in the writing process. See our post on overcoming limiting beliefs in music production for the collision exercise on creative risk taking.
  5. Use repetition to your advantage. Seriously. With enough repetition, anything can become a main melody or motif in a song. It’s one of the most powerful, rudimentary, yet overlooked tools in music production. Repeat a phrase. Repeat it with a subtle variation. Repeat it on different instrument. These moves will create a call-and-response pull in your music.
  6. On the flip-side, including one-time events is absolutely necessary for maintaining your listener’s interest and creating special, memorable moments within the arrangement. That could be a one-shot vocal chop, beastly drum fill, cascading dub delay… the options are endless. Find something that works for your track, and give it the special attention to detail it deserves.

When it’s all said and done, a good arrangement is one that steps out of the way to let the message in your music shine through. Chances are it will take multiple iterations to get right, but if you focus on subtracting to make room for what’s really grooving, you won’t go wrong. It takes practice, and most of all, it takes finishing songs to get in the habit of trusting your instinct and moving quickly.

Soon you’ll find that arrangement becomes an inseparable part of your workflow, all the way from the initial idea through the mixdown. I hope this post gives you a rock solid plan to start achieving that. Any favorite arrangement moves that you find yourself going back to? Let us know below!